What does ID mean in a tracklist? ID - ID, ID remix and the rest

By Ryan Poser, who builds ryser.idUpdated First published

The short answer

In a DJ tracklist, ID means unidentified: somebody heard the track, wrote down where it played, and left the name open because nobody knew it. ID - ID means neither the artist nor the title is known, Artist - ID means the artist is known but the title is not, and ID remix means a known track played in a version nobody can name. Most IDs are unreleased music: promos, private edits and the DJ's own new tracks.

In short

ID
Short for unidentified (from “ID?”, asking for a track's name). Not a genre, not an error.
ID - ID
Artist and title unknown. Usually an unreleased track.
Artist - ID
The artist is known, the title is not: often the DJ's own unreleased music.
ID remix, ID edit
A known track in a version nobody can name: a remix, an edit or a bootleg.
Why it stays ID
Recognition apps only know released music. A track that is not out yet is in no database.
How IDs get solved
Comments, tracklist sites, Reddit, the DJ, and the release itself, often months later.

ID, in one line

ID is DJ shorthand for a track that has not been identified. The word comes from the question people ask at the booth and type under a video: “ID?”, short for “what is this track?”. A tracklist that still has IDs is a tracklist with open questions, and answering them is a sport of its own.

How tracklists write it

You seeIt meansTypical reason
ID - IDNeither artist nor title knownAn unreleased track or a dubplate
Artist - IDThe artist is known, the title is notThe DJ or a friend playing new music
ID - ID (Artist edit)Who made the edit is known, the track is notAn edit made for the set
Artist - Title (ID remix)A known track in an unknown versionAn unreleased remix or a bootleg
Artist - Title w/ IDPlayed over an unknown trackAn acapella or a loop on top of another record
Artist - Title vs. IDA mashup with an unknown trackA live blend of two records

What does ID remix mean?

ID remix means the original is known but the version is not. You hear the vocal of a track everyone knows over a beat that is not on any release: the DJ is playing a remix that is not out yet, a bootleg somebody made, or an edit of their own. Tracklists write it as Artist - Title (ID remix) or (ID edit). When the remix comes out, the row gets the remixer's name.

Why so many tracks stay ID

Recognition apps match a recording against a database of released music. A track that was never released is not in any database, so the Shazam app, SoundHound and every other fingerprinting tool draw a blank, however clean the recording. That covers most IDs in a modern techno or house set: promos months away from release, private edits and tools the DJ made for that night.

The mix itself is the second reason. DJs play records faster or slower than released and blend two of them for a minute at a time. A phone app that hears ten seconds of a pitched, layered section often gives up even on a released track. That is not a true ID, just a gap in the tool.

How to find out what an ID was

  1. Write down the timestamp, for example 47:20, and keep the link to the set.
  2. Read the comments and the description. On YouTube and SoundCloud the timed comments are where most IDs get solved. Search the page for “ID” and the timestamp.
  3. Search the tracklist sites. 1001Tracklists collects the crowd's answers per set, and marks an ID once somebody names it.
  4. Run the whole set through a tool that listens to it. ryser.id names every released track it can, with its timestamp, and marks what it cannot name as unknown at the right moment, so you know exactly which minutes are still open.
  5. Ask people. Post the link and the timestamp on Reddit in r/IdentifyThisTrack or the genre's subreddit. On a public set on ryser.id, anyone signed in can suggest a name with Fix this ID under the row, and crowd IDs shows how those names are checked.
  6. Ask the DJ. Many answer under their own upload, especially about their own music, once a release date exists.

When an ID gets released

An ID does not stay one forever. Many unreleased tracks in big sets come out months later, and the tracklist sites update the row when they do. On ryser.id, the unknown rows of your own sets are watched: when one gets a name later, you get a mail.

Questions

What does ID mean in a DJ set?

Unidentified. ID marks a track in a tracklist that nobody has named yet. ID - ID means the artist and the title are both unknown.

What does ID remix mean?

A known track in a version nobody can name. The original is clear, but the remix or edit the DJ played has no name yet, usually because it is unreleased or a private edit.

Does ID mean the track is unreleased?

Usually, but not always. Most IDs are promos, private edits or the DJ's own new music. Some are old or obscure records that nobody in the comments recognised, and some are released tracks that a recognition app missed because the DJ pitched or layered them.

Why can't Shazam identify an ID?

The Shazam app matches what it hears against released music. A track that has not come out is in no database, so no app can name it, however clean the recording.

How do I find out what an ID is?

Note the exact timestamp, then read the comments and the description, search the set on 1001Tracklists, ask on Reddit (r/IdentifyThisTrack or the genre's subreddit) and ask the DJ. On a public set on ryser.id, anyone signed in can suggest a name with Fix this ID.

When does an ID get released?

There is no rule. Many IDs in big sets come out within months, some never do. Tracklist sites update the row once somebody names it.

Why does ryser.id show ID - ID on public set pages?

A public set page shows a row's name only when ryser.id stands behind it. Every other row reads ID - ID, the way DJs write it, and asks whoever knows the track to say so. See Public sets and the set library.

Got a set link? Get its tracklist.

Paste the link and ryser.id names every track it can, with the time it starts. No account? The quick peek under the box does the first 30 minutes for free and mails you the list.

All guides